The BBF has given sellers and their brokers an amazing marketplace to sell businesses. It has proved to be quite efficient in its ability to find the right buyer to buy businesses that enter the marketplace. And in today’s seller-favored landscape of business transactions, if a business is not selling, we can only deduce that it is overpriced. This issue is obvious, and the statistics show clearly that these businesses most likely will not sell. In this article, we will delve into some key reasons as to why overpriced businesses struggle to sell.
The Overpricing Dilemma: The #1 Reason Why Businesses Fail to Sell and Why Buyers Shun Them.
Educated Buyers: Modern consumers are more informed than ever before, thanks to the wealth of information available at their fingertips. Buyers conduct thorough research, understanding market trends, financial standings, and comparable sales. An overpriced business stands out like a sore thumb to educated buyers who can quickly identify discrepancies between the asking price and the actual value. Informed buyers are less likely to “make an offer,” leading to a prolonged listing period or, in some cases, no sale at all.
Comparative Shopping on the Internet: The internet has revolutionized the way people shop, and this holds true for business acquisitions as well. Potential buyers can effortlessly compare prices, features, and the overall value of businesses in the same industry or niche. A business that is perceived as overpriced online will struggle to attract serious inquiries, as buyers can easily find alternatives with better value propositions. The transparency provided by the internet has made it imperative for sellers to understand the marketplace and price accordingly.
Aversion to Negotiation: Negotiating the sale of a business can be a delicate dance, and some buyers are averse to the process altogether. When a business is overpriced, negotiations become more challenging, and potential buyers may be discouraged from engaging in the conversation. Buyers prefer transparent and fair pricing. Therefore, an overpriced business may create an atmosphere of distrust, hindering the negotiation process and causing the process to never even start. This may also be a generational trend worth consideration.
Fear of Offending Sellers: Buyers often tread carefully during the negotiation process, fearing that expressing concerns about the pricing may offend the sellers. This reluctance to discuss perceived overpricing can lead to a breakdown in communication and a failure to reach a mutually agreeable deal. Sellers who are open to constructive feedback and are willing to adjust their pricing strategy are more likely to engage in successful negotiations and ultimately close the deal.
Perception of Unreasonableness: The perception of a seller as being unreasonable or even delusional can stem from an overpriced listing. If a business is priced significantly higher than its market value, potential buyers may view the seller as unrealistic or out of touch with market realities. This perception can drive away serious buyers who are looking for fair and justifiable pricing. It may also call into question the seller’s representations of other items in the opportunity such as earnings claims.
Drop in Sales: The Evidence is Clear: Statistics indicate a clear correlation between overpricing and a failure to sell. When a business is priced more than 15% above its market value, the chances of a successful sale decrease significantly. This underscores the importance of accurately valuing a business, pricing it appropriately to attract potential buyers and facilitating a successful transaction process.
In conclusion, the primary reason businesses fail to sell is that they are overpriced. Educated buyers, the power of the internet, aversion to negotiation, fear of offending sellers, and the perception of unreasonableness are all factors that contribute to this dilemma. Again, buyers will not “just make an offer.” Brokers must help their sellers carefully consider market dynamics, give them professional advice, so they adopt a realistic pricing strategy in order to maximize their chances of a successful business sale in today’s marketplace. Simply stated, if you are trying to sell a business, and have yet to, your business is most likely overpriced.
Andy Cagnetta
M&AMI,CBI,CM&AP, BBF Board Member
CEO of Transworld Business Advisors
Seven Reasons Why a Buyer May Expect Working Capital to be Included in the Sale Price of a Business
What is working capital? Working capital represents the short-term liquidity and financial health of a business. Positive working capital can indicate the business is well-managed and financially stable. Working capital is the money available to meet current, short-term obligations. It is calculated by subtracting short-term liabilities from short-term assets. Short liabilities include accounts payable, salaries, taxes, and other debts/accrued expenses. Short-term assets include cash, accounts receivable, and inventory that will be converted into cash within twelve months.
Oftentimes, sellers are taken by surprise when a buyer demands a specific amount of working capital to be included in the sale price of a business. In lower-middle-market valuations based off EBITDA multiples, working capital is included in the price. In main street business valuations based off SDE multiples, working capital is not included in the price. However, with a stumbling economy, more sophisticated lower-middle-market buyers are reaching down into main street businesses and applying their expectations to main street acquisitions. So, why would a buyer want to include working capital in the acquisition?
Here are seven reasons why a buyer may expect working capital to be included:
1. Ensures Business Continuity
Working capital is essential for the day-to-day operations of a business. By including working capital in the sale price, the buyer ensures the business will have sufficient funds to continue its operations smoothly after the acquisition.
2. Creates Seamless Transition
Working capital helps create a smooth transitional period during which the buyer takes over the operations. By including working capital in the sale price, the buyer has immediate access to funds to cover initial expenses, pay suppliers and employees, handle any unexpected costs, etc. during the transition.
3. Avoids Additional Investments
Working capital avoids the need for the buyer to inject additional capital just to maintain the current operations of the business. By including working capital in the sale price, the buyer can avoid having to make an additional investment immediately after the acquisition.
4. Mitigates Risk
Working capital can indicate the business is well-managed and financially stable. By including working capital in the sale price, the buyer reduces the risk of acquiring a business that may be struggling to meet its short-term obligations.
5. Simplifies Negotiations
Working capital simplifies the negotiation process. By including working capital in the sale price, instead of negotiating a separate amount for working capital, both parties agree on a total purchase price that includes the estimated working capital needed to operate the business.
6. Avoids Disputes
Working capital can be a contentious issue in negotiations if not explicitly addressed. By including working capital in the sale price, both parties avoid potential disputes or disagreements over the specific amount of working capital at the time of the sale.
7. Simplifies Handing of A/R and A/P
Working capital simplifies the handling of accounts receivable (A/R) and accounts payable(A/P) after the sale. By including working capital in the sale price, A/R and A/P do not need to be allocated between the buyer and seller. The buyer can simply receive revenue and pay bills as if the sale never occurred.
It is important to note the inclusion of working capital in the sale price should be clearly defined in the purchase agreement. Both parties should agree on the methodology for calculating the working capital amount, any adjustments, and the target working capital amount at the time of the sale. Proper due diligence is crucial to ensure the working capital included in the sale price accurately reflects the needs of the business and is fair to both parties.
Sources: Bank of America and Chat GPT
Eric J. Gall
Edison Business Advisors
Eric is the registered broker and founder of Edison Business Advisors. Over the past 25 years, Eric has participated in many forms of business transactions closing in on $300M. He has earned 34 awards from BBF, IBBA, and M&A Source since 2010. Eric is the President of BBF Southwest Florida Region and serves on M&A Source Deal Market Committee and BBF State Board.
Buying a Business: What is the Real Value of a Business?
Using “multiples” to value a business may be a disservice to both the seller and buyer. “Multiples” may not represent the real value of the business.
Multiples are generally median or average values published in the BBF MLS or in Pratt Stats/Deal Stats. However, these are just convenient “midpoints” that do not represent any specific transaction. These multiples are based on historical information, a different market area, a different economic environment, a different seller’s perspective, etc. Unless the transaction being “valued” is truly an average transaction, then using these multiples is misleading.
These multiples are applied to recent historical financial performance of the business (transaction being contemplated).
What is the “real” value of a business? Standard concepts/definitions used credentialed valuation specialists to value a business are:
- The “Present value of future economic benefits to be derived by the owner of the business.”
- The price that would be agreed on between a willing buyer and a willing seller, with neither being required to act, and both having reasonable knowledge of all relevant facts.
Future economic benefits are important relevant facts in valuing a transaction and are based on:
- The Industry: Is it in a growth, mature or declining stage
- The Market Area: Is it growing, stable or declining with respect to population, household income, etc.
- The Business: Growing, stable or declining
- The Terminal Value: An estimated economic benefit to be realized at divestiture
- The Owner: Reasons for exit
A Real-Life Example:
This was a rapidly growing business in a mature industry but in a growing market. The following graphs show historical performance and statistically projected growth.
This business should have been “valued”, given knowledge of all the relevant facts, based on future economic benefits. Even though the industry was mature the market area was growing in both population and economic prosperity and the business was growing due to identification of a niche in the market, good management and “sweat equity”. This resulted in increasing transactions, stable to slightly increasing revenue per transaction and increasing gross revenue. Bottom-line was increasing also due to reduction in early year start-up costs. There were substantial future economic benefits in the business.
Nonetheless, the buyer wanted to focus on multiples of historical performance. Why?
Jim Bolinger
Truforte Business Group
Mr. Bolinger’s career has spanned 45 years working in finance, organizational strategy, business planning and as a small business owner. Positions have included:
- Senior Manager, Audit Services Division, International CPA firm
- Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, large community hospital
- Partner, national consulting firm focused on strategy as well as mergers & acquisitions
- Managing Partner & Co-founder, national consulting firm focused on strategy, business planning, mergers & acquisitions and business valuations
- Business Broker, Truforte Business Group
Education:
- MBA with Honors, University Notre Dame
- Bachelor of Science in Business, Indiana University.
Publications and Presentations:
- Selling a Business? Avoid These Mistakes, Southwest Florida Business Today (February 2021)
- Why Now is the Best Time to Buy/Sell a Business, Above Board Chamber webinar (November 12, 2020)
- Preparation Boosts Success When Selling a Business, Southwest Florida Business Today (August 2019)
- Buying or Selling a Business: Strategies and Tactics (SCORE, South Bend, IN and Fort Myers, FL)
- Medical Practice Valuations, Executive Checklist Series (an Arista publication)
- So You Want To Start A Business (SCORE, Fort Myers, FL)
- Understanding Financial Statements (SCORE Mentor Boot Camp, Southwest Florida)
- Leading Change/Managing Transitions: The Human Factor (Indiana Society of CPA’s)
- Sustainable Collaboration: Precedents to Success, Executive Checklist Series (an Arista publication)
Professionalism at its Core
I recently completed a comprehensive program of next-level professional education, achieving the Master Certified Business Intermediary designation. In this inaugural Masters cohort, I was fortunate to learn with some of the industry’s most professional and vastly experienced business intermediaries and M&A advisors worldwide; in addition to that, the professors that taught each course were the best of the best, names that anyone in our industry would recognize instantly. I share all of this to set the context for where I’m going in this article.
The last segment of this course was focused on ethics and professionalism. One could question the need for a discussion on this topic when there was an easily combined three hundred-plus years of experience and undoubtedly professionalism amongst my peers. What could be taught about ethics to this level of intermediaries and M&A advisors? When, in fact, we only explored a small portion of the subject that could have been worthy of further examination.
These discussions sparked thoughts that made me reflect on the years of my practice and the people I have encountered not only as a broker of record for my firm but also, probably more importantly, over these past three years as chairman of the Business Brokers of Florida. The subject goes beyond the people working directly in our industry as it expands into associates in affiliates, we work with daily to get our deals done.
During the four-hour discussion, we discussed several different topics of what ethics and professionalism mean to teach us as a group of individuals accountable to our principles to keep and maintain those standards. We all saw common ground on the theological proverb of “do unto others, as you would have them, do unto you“ as a guiding principle to what should be the foundation of everyone’s character. In a perfect world, this would be nice.
The challenge with this practice of thought is that one risks dealing with individuals with their own thoughts and opinions based upon their own life experiences, spheres of influence, and, hopefully, theological upbringing. Some folks may be guided by cultural effects shaping their approach to what many would consider right or wrong. So, what one person feels was a usual way of life may be utterly offensive to another.
In our discussion groups, we challenged each other and the associations we connected to formulate something that reaches beyond the word “ethics,” as we felt that this doesn’t truly encompass the vast avenues of guiding principles or “code,” as it were. Our discussion groups dissected over twenty-five industry-specific topics, from “balancing the relationships between our principals” to “incentives or detriments that could affect the outcome of our deals” and much more impactful subjects on what we encounter daily. We could all agree that even though we do our best in our firms and deals, not everyone we deal with will have that same mindset. When faced with situations that are questionable in a deal or others as it pertains to something dubious in character, it is up to each of us to take a couple of steps back, reassess the circumstances, and confront the matter with a moral high ground.
Those who don’t operate in the realm of steadfast moral character stand out as the thorn in any industry or society and are what causes people to distrust one another. I pray that we can develop into a society of brothers and sisters, all working toward a common goal of greatness for each other and ourselves. It all starts with us doing our best to inspire and encourage others through our examples of virtuous character. This is the foundation for us as individuals and in our professional standards of practice in our firms and associations.
Ultimately, this course strengthened my confidence by realizing that the folks I have worked closely with over the years meet and even exceed those standards. I couldn’t be more honored and humbled to witness and be a part of this transformation in our Business Brokers of Florida membership. We continue to set the standard… professionalism at its core.
Joe Shemansky CBI, M&AMI, CM&AP
Chairman
Business Brokers of Florida
Understanding the E-2 Visa Program
If you work in the field of business brokerage you most likely have heard of the “E-2 Investment Visa”. However, this program is little understood and there are many misconceptions. In the following article I attempt to clarify what this program is and how we as business brokers are uniquely qualified to offer assistance.
The E-2 visa is an investment based nonimmigrant visa, which allows citizens of certain Countries to live and work in the USA by investing in an existing U.S. business. By buying a US based business the E-2 applicant gains the right to live and work in the United States for a limited period of time. Usually, two years with the possibility of subsequent 2-year extensions. There is no limit to the potential number of extensions. The spouse and unmarried children (under 21) of the applicant may also join them in the US. Once here the spouse can apply for permission to work.
There is a second type of investment visa known as the EB-5. This differs in two important respects from the E-2. First of all, the amount of required investment for an EB-5 is significantly higher. Secondly the EB-5 is an immigrant program offering permanent residency to the investor. In this article I will focus on the E-2 program as this is the one you will most likely encounter.
The E-2 program requires a “substantial investment”, but no specific amount is set by law, so this is somewhat open to interpretation.
It is important to understand the type of business that will qualify for an E-2 investment. I look for small businesses with W2 employees. A business that can provide an income to support the investor and his/her family. The applicant will need to provide the immigration service with a business plan. They will want to establish a Company, typically LLC and obtain a Federal Tax number – EIN. Next a bank account should be opened in the United States. This can be a difficult step and the investor will likely need to be present to do this. Lastly the funds for the investment should be deposited in the Bank. These funds will need to be “sourced” to show their origin.
At this time the applicant will complete their due diligence on the business and accomplish the other normal steps of an acquisition. The attorney now submits the application to the Immigration Service. In the penultimate step the applicant will be called for an interview at the Embassy in their Country of origin. If everything goes well at the interview the Visa will be approved.
When working with an E-2 applicant my advice is that they retain a US based Immigration Attorney. This is a complex process, and the applicant will require assistance from an experienced Lawyer. I will not work with an E-2 applicant until they have engaged the attorney and put us in contact as we must work together.
The role of the business broker is critical in this process. We located a suitable business and made the necessary introductions. As with any deal we guide buyers and sellers through the process. The process from beginning to end will typically take six months or more. So, patience on the part of all parties is required. However, once an E-2 investor is committed I have never seen them back out of a deal due to cold feet.
The commitment of the buyer and the special circumstances involved make this a very rewarding deal for the Broker to bring to a successful close.
Yi Lee is an immigration lawyer with the law firm of David Vedder in Daytona Beach. In preparation for this article, I asked him several questions. I found his answers so informative that I have included the discussion below.
We typically suggest for minimum investment to be around $150,000 but I have had one approved for $90k. We like the range of $150k to $250k.
To qualify, the investor has to be a citizen of the treaty country that shares trade and commerce with the US. Not all countries can avail of the E-2 treaty visa. For example, India and China are not E-2 countries. For the UK, it is not enough to show that the investor is a citizen of the United Kingdom, but the investor must also show domicile in UK proper.
Any bona fide lawful business can be invested for the E-2 benefit. The investment must be substantial, which is determined on a case-by-case basis. Return on investment must be more than marginal. A marginal enterprise is one that does not have the present or future capacity to generate more than enough income to provide a minimal living for the treaty investor.
While creation of jobs, i.e., hiring of employees, is not necessary to obtain the E-2 benefit, it certainly helps to show that the investor is creating US jobs.
The biggest challenge when applying for the E-2 visas at Post is that every consulate has slightly different requirements. Overall, however, I have experienced that E-2 Officers are generally very reasonable and want to approve these visas to drive foreign investment into the US.
One piece of advice I would give to an applicant for an E-2 visa is to document everything! Have an accountant document the source of funds and show that it is a legitimate source. Create the LLC and capitalize the business account, if possible, before submitting the application. An organized application is a readily approvable application!
The typical timeline from application to approval is around 3 to 4 months. The fastest turnaround time I have seen was 2 months.
Anthony John Rigney is the owner and Broker with Quorum Business Advisors, LLC. He entered the business brokerage industry in 2008 and has been a member of the BBF since that time. For several years he served as President of the North Florida District.
Anthony Rigney
Owner and Broker
Quorum Business Advisors, LLC